I think they all work on the right day. The B-Mobile IMO is the worst “looking” of the bunch. The head is goofy looking, and the body is small. Both the Pretty Boy and the B-Mobile colors on the head just have WAY too much white for my taste…..so does the new Casanova by Ol’ Tom. the Flambeau has the right coloration but I think the real key is the real tail feathers that you put in them. The one with the best looking head is Cherokee Sports inflatable but I think the body is too shiny. The birds key in on the iridescence of the natural feahers.
I am not a “real” fan of gobbler decoys for archery. Will they work? Of course, but I think you just can’t go wrong with a good looking hen decoy, you have less chance of spooking a bird. It just seems like every hunt I see on a DVD with a gobbler decoy the bird always seems “nervous” vs. a hen, especially a mounted hen, he is more content.
Back to your question, with a repaint to the head, the Pretty Boy.